Pending Appeals to Higher Courts

Appeals from Board of Tax Appeals' decisions by date of appeal, beginning with appeals pending on January 1, 2008. Last updated: July 2, 2008.

---

Appeals Pending before the Supreme Court:

Appeal Number	Name	Date of Appeal	Court	Number	Result
05-H-1206	Bd. of Edn. of the Olentangy Local Schools v. Delaware Cty. Bd. of Rev., Delaware Cty. Auditor, and Ohio Investment Dst.	6/17/08	Supreme Court	08-1178
05-H-1205	Bd. of Edn. of the Olentangy Local Schools v. Delaware Cty. Bd. of Rev., Delaware Cty. Auditor, and Ohio Investment Dst.	6/17/08	Supreme Court	08-1176
05-H-1436	Olmsted Falls Bd. of Educ. v. Cuyahoga Cty. Bd. of Rev., Cuyahoga Cty. Auditor, & M&B Olmsted, LLC.	5/28/08	Supreme Court	08-1035
06-M-786 & 06-M-787	Realty Income Corp. v. Lake Cty. Bd. of Rev. & Lake Cty. Auditor.	4/15/08	Supreme Court	08-709
06-A-331, 06-A-333 & 06-A-345	CCleveland OH Realty I, LLC & CCleveland OH Realty II, LLC & Bd. of Educ. of the Cleveland Municipal School Dist. V. Cuyahoga Cty. Bd. of Rev & Cuyahoga Cty. Auditor.	4/4/08	Supreme Court	08-636
05-A-992	Colonial Terrace Apartments II (An Ohio General Part.) v. Washington Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	3/20/08 (Cross 3/28/08)	Supreme Court	08-0561
05-A-993	Colonial Terrace Apartments (An Ohio General Part.) v. Washington Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	3/20/08 (Cross 3/28/08)	Supreme Court	08-0560
05-A-987	Colonial Village Ltd., An Ohio Ltd. Part. v. Washington Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	3/20/08 (Cross 3/28/08)	Supreme Court	08-0559
04-A-574	Colonial Village Ltd. v. Washington Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	2/28/08 (Cross 3/3/08)	Supreme Court	08-443
05-V-1726, 06-V-99 & 06-H-117	Cleveland Clinic Foundation et al. v. Wilkins	2/22/08	Supreme Court	08-411
05-A-749	Woda Ivy Glen Ltd. Part. v. Fayette Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	2/11/08	Supreme Court	08-312
06-M-398	Plazamill Ltd. Part. & Surrey Sawmill Acquisition, LLC v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	2/8/08	Supreme Court	08-305	May 22, 2008. Remanded upon Settlement.
07-T-176	James E. and Verna K. Gibson v. Levin	1/17/08	Supreme Court	08-129
06-T-1007	Carl Robert Wagenknecht Jr. v. Wilkins	1/14/08	Supreme Court	08-95
05-M-1683	Northeast Ohio Psychiatric Institute v. Wilkins	1/10/08	Supreme Court	08-33
05-T-1627	Abdul and Rawnaq A. Hafiz v. Wilkins	12/31/07	Supreme Court	07-2450
05-A-1386	Healthsouth Corporation v. Wilkins	12/10/07	Supreme Court	07-2281
06-V-783	D. Mark Fife & Patricia Fife v. Greene Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	11/27/07	Supreme Court	07-2213
05-M-1566	Hudson CSD Bd. of Educ. V. Summit Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	11/21/07	Supreme Court	07-2181
05-T-902	AEI Net Lease Income and Growth Fund v. Erie Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	11/13/07	Supreme Court	07-2101
05-K-202	The Ohio Bell Telephone Co. v. Wilkins.	10/1/07	Supreme Court	07-1807
06-T-635	Southside Community Development Corp. v. Wilkins & Youngstown Bd. of Education	9/17/07	Supreme Court	07-1722
06-R-1041	Keith A. Brown and Noel P. Brown v. Wilkins.	9/13/07	Supreme Court	07-1718
06-B-818	Lee v. Margulies	9/11/07	Supreme Court	07-1688	Jan. 23, 2008. Not accepted for review.
04-T-1152	Gasper Township Board of Trustees v. Preble County Budget Commission, et al.	7/16/07	Supreme Court	07-1282
05-M-1069	Cincinnati School Dist. Bd. of Education v. Hamilton Cty. Bd. of Rev., Anchor Lyons Limited Partnership, et al.	7/6/07	Supreme Court	07-1217	2008-Ohio-2450 May 28, 2008. Affirmed.
03-T-1139	UBS Financial Services, Inc. f/k/a/ Paine Webber, Inc. v. Zaino	6/22/07	Supreme Court	07-1129
05-R-329 & 05-R-330	Columbus Bd. of Educ. & South-Western City Schools Bd. of Educ. v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Rev., Max E. Cougill, et al.	6/18/07	Supreme Court	07-1086	2008-Ohio-2449 May 28, 2008. Affirmed.
02-M-170, 02-M-171 & 02-M-172	Hon. Carroll E. Newman, Adams County Auditor v. Wilkins, et al.	6/13/07 (Cross 6/18 & 6/25)	Supreme Court	07-1054	116 Ohio St.3d 1205, 2007-Ohio-5507 Oct. 23, 2007. Tax Commissioner’s Appeal Dismissed. Two Cross Appeals Pending.
04-B-183	City of Toledo, et al. v. McAndrew	5/21/07	Supreme Court	07-938	2008-Ohio-119 March 19, 2008. Reversed & Remanded.
06-B-48	Sylvania Church of God v. Wilkins	5/17/07	Supreme Court	07-924	2008-Ohio-2448 May 28, 2008. Affirmed.
05-B-730	Knickerbocker Properties, Inc. XLII v. Delaware Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	5/14/07	Supreme Court	07-896
05-M-1098	Hon. Dusty Rhodes, Hamilton Cty. Auditor v. Hamilton Cty. Bd. of Rev., MA Richter Villa Ltd. & Vigran Bros. Villa Ltd. & Bd. of Educ. Of Princeton City School Dist.	4/6/07	Supreme Court	07-615	2008-Ohio-1595 April 9, 2008. Affirmed.
05-B-638	Bd. of Educ. of the Dublin City Schools v. Frankin Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	3/27/07	Supreme Court	07-550	2008-Ohio-1588 April 9, 2008. Affirmed.
04-K-349	AP Hotels of Illinois v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Rev., Franklin Cty. Auditor, and the Bd. of Ed. of the Canal Winchester City School Dist.	3/16/07	Supreme Court	07-478	2008-Ohio-2565 June 3, 2008. Affirmed.
04-V-1294	Polaris Amphitheater Concerts, Inc. v. Delaware Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	2/22/07	Supreme Court	07-347	2008-Ohio-2454 May 29, 2008. Rev’d & Remanded.
05-K-82	Marc Glassman, Inc. v. Wilkins – Appeal now pending in Supreme Court from Eighth District Court of Appeals’ decision reported at Cuyahoga App. No. 87766, 2006-Ohio-6591.	2/20/07	Supreme Court	07-328
05-R-591	Cummins Property Services, LLC v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	2/1/07	Supreme Court	07-195	2008-Ohio-1473 April 3, 2008. Affirmed.
04-R-230	Episcopal School of Cincinnati v. Wilkins	1/22/07	Supreme Court	07-126	2008-Ohio-939 March 12, 2008. Affirmed.
05-T-1301	City of Elyria, et al. v. Lorain Cty. Budget Comm., et al.	12/28/06	Supreme Court	06-2390	2008-Ohio-940 Mar. 12, 2008. Reversed & Remanded.
04-T-1166	City of Elyria, et al. v. Lorain Cty. Budget Comm., et al.	12/28/06	Supreme Court	06-2389	2008-Ohio-940 Mar. 12, 2008. Reversed & Remanded.
03-T-1533	City of Elyria, et al. v. Lorain Cty. Budget Comm., et al.	12/13/06	Supreme Court	06-2293	2008-Ohio-940 Mar. 12, 2008. Reversed & Remanded.
04-T-187 & 04-T-188	Daimler Chrysler Corp. v. Wilkins	9/15/06	Supreme Court	06-1731	2008-Ohio-259 Jan. 30, 2008. Reversed.
03-K-1876	Columbia Gas Transmission Corp. v. Zaino.	7/31/06 (Cross 8/7/06)	Supreme Court	06-1443	2008-Ohio-511 Feb. 14, 2008. Reversed. Cross appeal overruled.
04-M-380 & 04-M-1283	Shiloh Automotive, Inc. v. Wilkins.	7/21/06 (Cross 7/31/06)	Supreme Court	06-1384	2008-Ohio-68 Jan. 16, 2008. Decision Affirmed And Cross-Appeal Dismissed.

---

---

Appeals Pending before Courts of Appeal:

Appeal Number	Name	Date of Appeal	Court	Number	Result
06-K-838	Springfield City School Dist. Bd. of Educ. v. Clark Cty. Bd. of Rev., Clark Cty. Auditor & Nancy Wilson.	5/28/08	Clark County Court of Appeals
06-R-50	York Temple Country Club v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Rev., Franklin Cty. Auditor & Worthington City Schools Bd. of Educ.	4/30/08	Franklin County Court of Appeals
06-T-1478	G. Rodney Miller v. Montgomery Co. Bd. of Rev., et al.	4/17/08	Montgomery County Court of Appeals	CA22720
05-V-1441 & 05-V-1442	SSN II Ltd. and Randal R. Sadler, Trustee v. Warren Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	3/17/08	Warren County Court of Appeals
07-H-963	General Commodities Candy & Tobacco, LLC v. Levin	2/14/08	Franklin County Court of Appeals	08AP-126	2008-Ohio-3173 June 26, 2008. Affirmed.
06-T-1239	Richard Szymen v. Monroe Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	11/26/07	Monroe County Court of Appeals
05-T-1605 & 05-T-1642	1524 Indianola Avenue, LLC v. Franklin Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	11/13/07	Franklin County Court of Appeals
07-R-269	Rome P. and Margaret F. Busa v. Levin.	9/14/07	Cuyahoga County Court of Appeals
07-H-268	Anthony J. and Rebecca S. Busa v. Levin.	9/14/07	Cuyahoga County Court of Appeals
05-T-1464	City of Marion, Ohio v. Marion City Bd. of Review	9/10/07	Marion County Court of Appeals	9-07-37	2008-Ohio-2496 May 27, 2008. Dismissed – Lack of Jurisdiction.
05-M-1400	Elyria City School Dist. Bd. of Educ. v. Lorain Cty. Bd. of Rev., Robert P. Ellis, Jr., Trustee, et al.	6/29/07	Lorain County Court of Appeals
06-B-818	Hee S. Lee v. Hamilton Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	6/20/07	Hamilton County Court of Appeals	C-070478	April 7, 2008. Dismissed.
06-Z-780	James B. & Tina D. Renacci v. Wilkins	6/15/07	Medina County Court of Appeals	07 CA 0061-M
04-K-749 & 04-K-750	MCI Metro Access Transmission Services, LLC et al. v. Wilkins	5/11/07	Franklin County Court of Appeals
07-A-62	Benjamin Cran v. Levin	5/2/07	Franklin County Court of Appeals	07 APH 05 0384
05-A-1108	Powderhorn Country Club, LLC v. Lake Cty. Bd. of Rev., et al.	4/19/07	Lake County Court of Appeals	2007-L-071	2008-Ohio-1024 March 7, 2008. Affirmed.
05-H-359	The Old West End Association v. Wilkins	11/22/06	Lucas County Court of Appeals	L-06-1374	2008-Ohio-366 Jan. 18, 2008. Affirmed.

---

Go to...
[State Front Page] [Board of Tax Appeals Home Page]

These matters are provided for informational purposes and are believed to be accurate. The actual orders and decisions are contained in the Board's journals. By publication of these matters, neither the State of Ohio nor the Board assumes any liability for any errors or omissions, or in any other respect.